Call them the littlest
activists. A group of middle school girls, angered by a smokeless
tobacco billboard near their school, took on the giant Philip Morris
tobacco company. And they won.
The 13 girls, seventh and
eighth graders at Horace Mann Middle School in San Francisco, wrote a
letter to the firm, charging it with violating its own policy of not
permitting tobacco ads within 500 feet of school grounds. The
smokeless tobacco billboard was 146 feet from the school grounds,
they wrote.
"We feel it's unfair to us
that you are targeting young people like us," they wrote to the
company's Chief Executive Officer. "We are Chicana, African
American, Irish American, Latina and Filipina young women of San
Francisco."
They collected signatures
for a petition and sent copies of their efforts to Mayor Jordan and
Supervisor Angela Alioto.
The company did not respond
to the letter. But the sign came down.
"They shouldn't be targeting
us with their ads," said 13 year old Mayra Morell. "They should
target people who're old enough to make stupid decisions...like
smoking."
Thursday the girls had a
victory celebration, with a "Dunk Joe Camel" booth at the school's
annual festival.
For Cindy Manriquez, 12, who
nagged her father for years before he kicked the habit, it was very
important to see the advertisement come down. "Those ads make it seem
like it's OK to smoke...and it's not," she said.
Joycelyn Bunac, 12, said she
just wanted Philip Morris to recognize that it had violated its
policy and should do something about it.
Even fellow student Jeffrey
Henderson, who didn't participate in the letter writing, said he
agreed with the girls. "It shows that they care about us...and they
were willing to take a stand for our health," he said.
"This is very empowering for
the kids," said physical education teacher Mike Beltrean, "and it
gives them a chance to be more socially responsible."
A spokeswoman for Philip
Morris in New York said the company did not target people under 18.
"And our policy has been that we do not respond to letters written by
anyone under 18." she said. The company will send its response to
Horace Mann Principal Richard Murphy.
San Francisco Health
Director Sandra Hernandez said the company's letter writing policy
didn't make sense because children should be able to have an opinion
about their health, and Philip Morris should be willing to
respond.
She said she hoped the
children would continue to fight tobacco advertisements. "I think
it's fabulous... organizing to maintain a healthy community, and this
reflects a tremendous amount of health education effort by the middle
school," she said.
Even as they celebrated
their victory, the girls were turning their attention to the ad that
replaced the Philip Morris billboard-one for beer.
"They should put something
else up," Cindy Manriquez said. "They just traded one bad ad for
another."